Well, I have been following this one of and on for the past few hours. Initially, I was disgusted that a person of such stature should be dealt with in this manner.

tangent : I am sure, the humble man he is, he will never raise his voice against an incident where he is treated like a common person. Even during his tenure as President he rarely lived in the grandiose of the Rashtrapati Bhavan, preferring a more humble abode nearby. BUT the point is that a person like him deserves to be treated with respect.

But a part of me also felt if it will be hypocritical not to apply the same law to all citizens of the country. This is like a perfect moral dilemma. You have got the law on one hand and your respect for the great man on the other. I think the point here is not that Dr. Kalam is an important person. What needs to be looked into are the reasons that he was detained in the first place. My gut feeling is that he is nothing but a victim of racial profiling. I know respectable people – doctors, homemakers etc. who have almost been strip searched on one or more visits to the United States. Its just something thats NOW in the news Because its happened with a famous person.

So, the question is, was the airline ignorant of his status? Did it decide to go ahead with a frisk not knowing about him? Or was it aware of who he is and still decided to go ahead with it? In all these cases, (hate to sound cynical but still) I feel one thing that is common is the preconcieved notion that a south asian man with a muslim name should be specially frisked. [Yes !! they always say its "standard procedure" yada yada,  as they said this time too ; they always do that!] But sadly, that is the kind of world we live in today. What happened is unfortunate but its not the first time a respectable man, this time a VIP, has been dealt with awkwardly.

With all this in mind, I’d say the Bureau of Civil Aviation Security is PROBABLY doing the right thing by filing an FIR and going to the full extent of the law to persecute the “unrepentant” Continental airline. But I am NOT totally convinced that its the IDEAL thing to do and thats simply because , unfortunately, such incidents are due to a mentality which is sadly nothing but the a product of the circumstances of the world we live in.

It all started with the “racist attacks on Indian students in Australia”. Since I was in Sydney at that time, it struck me as a bit odd that suddenly a community was allegedly being attacked for no reason. Upon talking with people who have been here for many years, my suspicion was confirmed – media hype. Indians -or migrants in general -  have never had it TOTALLY easy here and there have been numerous attacks in the past too. The person I talked to had himself been beaten up once 9 years back. Come to think about it, Australia is a big country with cities that are quite cosmopolitan in nature. I just ask those who hype up these matters, which major western city does NOT have regular crimes against migrants. Dont New York, LA, London et al have crime problems. What the hell do you think will happen , if you put an Indian guy in a dark alley at 2 a.m??

What was worse, was the way the Indian students responded after their was a surge in attacks…They were saying things like “Indians work very hard!! We dont like to fight. Indians should not be attacked”. Just their tone – it wasnt right. The point is simple – nobody need hurt anybody. Nobody cares if Indians work very hard. AND sadly protests of the kind that these guys did over here, were in my opinion counter-productive.

When you know you cant defend yourself against someone, you dont protest and draw attention to yourself – get me if you can. This is not about “justice,freedom” or whatever utopian ideal one uses to justify protests of this sort.Its about being practical, you simply dont play fire with fire when your matchstick is too damn short. (EDIT : lol, weird metaphor O_o) You burn yourself.

And who the hell are we Indians to even mention racism? Why did some of us cringe when we heard Mayawati may be PM? Havent we been racist for centuries? We have discriminated not just against people of different colour, not just against people of different religion, not just against people of different states but even people of a different caste of our own damn religion. Nevermind the media, they never had much to do anyways except hype up non-issues. Lets not throw stones when we ourselves live in glass houses.

Speaking to retired civil servants, who met him on Tuesday night to discuss national issues, President Asif Ali Zardari said militants and extremists had been “deliberately created and nurtured” as a policy for “short-term tactical objectives.”“Let us be truthful and make a candid admission of the reality,” the President told the retired federal secretaries and senior bureaucrats.

Seeing that there has been no denial or “I was quoted out of context”, we should believe that Zardari has openly come clean on his country’s behalf. There used to be a time when even a hint of such an admission by a Pakistani official (forget President) was unheard of. It was just something you did not do. India was perceived as, and by many still is, an existential threat.

But (am an optimist) it seems Pakistan has started coming to terms with the real threat – from within. The point is not the origin of the threat ( don’t we know that already), the point is that probably they have started realising it themselves. They too have seen a lot of violence perpetrated by people similar to the guys who they nurtured for “short term tactical objectives”. And it is probably not surprising how they have started cooperating with the US over the drone strikes in the North Western tribal areas. Although the huge amount of “foreign aid” certainly is a major factor behind the perceived increase in cooperation. Its probably also the best way US could get Pakistan to play along – carrot and stick approach.

I am sound cynical, but I wouldn’t read much into this till they actually take some concrete action. India has gotten itself burnt too many times, to get carried away by just another ’statement’. But still, lets ignore the grey cloud for now and look at that really dim (but there ) silver lining.

]]> http://wlog.suvirjain.com/2009/07/10/too-little-too-late/feed/ 0 http://wlog.suvirjain.com/2009/07/08/iraq-what-now/ http://wlog.suvirjain.com/2009/07/08/iraq-what-now/#comments Tue, 07 Jul 2009 16:52:45 +0000 Suvir http://wlog.suvirjain.com/?p=7 So, its been more that 5 years since US invaded Iraq and brought down Saddam Hussein. So what if they didnt find the WMD’s , Uncle Sam saved poor Iraqis from a dictator. Well, I dont want to get into all that – its been done too many times and its futile now.

Luckily for Iraq, Obama is clearly living up to his compaign promise of pulling out the troops from Iraq. Iraq might still be a violent place but mind you,, its much better than a year back. The security situation is getting better and the Iraqi security forces, trained by the coalition,  would now be in charge of the security of this fragile country.

In the aftermath of America’s decision to pull out of Iraq, it was the Iraqi response that was interesting. Nouri Al Maliki clearly seems confident that his forces will be more than upto the task. But there is also a touch of arrogance. From the way the prime minister has been talking, one would be easily fooled into thinking that their own security forces have everything under control. I agree that they are a proud people who will not rain flowers on the departing forces. But I cant help thinking that the departure of US forces may not be the ideal thing for Iraq.

With so many guerilla groups still active in the country, its only be a matter of time before the security forces face multiple problems like a spike in militancy, traitors in its ranks. It will be a testing time for the country and the way it deals with it would define its future. Iraq holds its destiny in its own hands. It got what it wanted – exit of the coalition forces. And now it needs to brace itself for the tough times ahead.

Thinking about it in retrospect now, the world would have been such a better place if the US has just left Iraq alone. Thats the beauty if retrospect thinking